Showing feedback is most useful as a pattern, not as single comments. One buyer who disliked the kitchen tells you about that buyer; five buyers who all mention the kitchen, or who all compare your home with the same house down the street, tell you what the market is saying. Sort what you hear into three groups: comments about price, comments about condition or presentation, and comments about things no one can change, such as the lot or the street. Then act on the groups you can change, starting with the one that comes up most.
How we collect it
After each showing, we ask the buyer's agent the same short set of questions, so the answers can be compared:
- How does the home compare with the others your buyer has seen at this price?
- Is the price where your buyer expected for this home?
- What did your buyer like most, and what gave them pause?
- Is your buyer likely to make an offer, and if not, what would change that?
Agents answer more candidly when the questions are specific and when they know the comments go to us, not straight to you. We send you a summary each week with the patterns, not only the individual notes, and we tell you what we think they mean.
Comments that point to price
"Nice home, but we found more for the money." "It's priced above what we saw in the neighborhood." "We'd need to see it come down." When several agents say versions of these, especially from buyers who toured the home and then bought or offered elsewhere, the price is the message. It rarely helps to wait for a buyer who disagrees with the others.
Activity tells you the same thing. Steady showings with no offers usually points to price against the homes buyers compare yours with. Few showings at all can point to price too, or to how the home looks online. Our luxury pricing guide covers when and how to adjust.
Comments that point to condition or presentation
"Needs updating." "The photos showed more light than we saw." "The back yard felt unfinished." These are often cheaper to fix than a price change. A deep clean, paint, lighting, landscaping or a staging change can move how buyers see a home within a week or two. If you used Compass Concierge, the cost of those changes can be fronted and repaid when the home sells, usually from your proceeds at closing, or earlier if the listing ends or 12 months pass (Compass program terms apply). Our staging guide covers where that money usually does the most.
If buyers keep raising the same repair, such as a roof, foundation or HVAC question, a pre-listing inspection or a repair estimate on hand can answer it before it reaches an offer. Our pre-listing inspection guide covers what usually comes up.
Comments about what can't change
A busy street, a sloped lot, a floor plan a buyer doesn't want, the distance to a school. You can't change these, but they still matter. They are part of what the price has to account for, and they shape who the right buyer is. A home on a busier street can still sell well to a buyer who values the lot or the house more; it needs to be priced and presented for that buyer.
When to change something
We look at the feedback, the showing count and any change in the homes competing with yours, and we recommend one change at a time so you can see what it does. As a rule of thumb, if the same price comment comes up again and again in the first weeks on the market, it is time to talk about price. If the comments are about presentation, fix those first and give it a little more time. Either way, we bring you the evidence and a recommendation, and the decision is yours.
What feedback can't tell you
Feedback is what buyers' agents choose to share, and some will be polite rather than candid. A buyer who loved the home may not offer; a buyer who said little may write the strongest offer. That is why we read feedback next to the numbers: showings, second visits, disclosure requests and offers.
How you launch matters too. Some homes do best as a Compass Private Exclusive, marketed only within the Compass brokerage, or as a Coming Soon, marketed online through Compass.com and Redfin.com, before the home reaches the MLS. Early feedback from a private or Coming Soon launch can tell you whether the price and presentation are right before the MLS launch. Others do best on the open market from day one. We'll tell you which one fits your home and why.
Talk to us about your home
Joe and Cara Keenan lead every consultation, negotiation and closing themselves. Keenan Group at Compass is Austin's #1 Real Estate Team (Austin Board of Realtors, 2024), with more than 25 years in Austin real estate and $1B+ in career sales. If your home is on the market and the feedback isn't adding up, call us at (512) 415-7653 and we will read it with you.
Frequently asked questions
How do I get feedback after a showing?
Your listing agent asks each buyer's agent after the showing. Specific questions get better answers: how the home compares with others at the price, whether the price fits, what the buyer liked and what gave them pause, and whether they are likely to offer.
What does it mean when I get lots of showings but no offers?
Usually that buyers are interested enough to see the home but are choosing others they compare it with. Most often that points to price against those homes. Sometimes it points to a condition or presentation issue that comes up in the feedback.
Should I lower my price after negative feedback?
Not after one comment. Look for a pattern across several showings. If the same price comment keeps coming up, a price change is worth discussing. If the comments are about condition or presentation, fix those first.
Can I see the exact feedback from buyers' agents?
Yes. We share the individual comments along with a weekly summary of the patterns and what we think they mean.
Why is showing feedback sometimes unhelpful?
Some agents are polite rather than candid, and some don't reply at all. That is why we read feedback next to the showing count, second visits and offers, rather than on its own.
Build a Personalized Austin Plan
Every household's Austin math is different. Start with a public plan, compare neighborhoods, schools, lifestyle priorities, and price bands, then save it when personalization matters.


