When the buyer's appraisal comes in below your contract price, the lender will lend only against the lower value, so the gap has to be covered or the deal changes. You have four paths: the buyer brings more cash, you lower the price, you meet somewhere in between, or the buyer's lender is asked to reconsider the value with better comparable sales. Which one is open to you depends first on what your contract says about the appraisal, so that is where we start.
Read the contract before you react
In Texas, a financed purchase includes the third party financing addendum. Under it, if the buyer's lender decides the property does not satisfy its requirements, including the appraisal, the buyer can end the contract on or before the third day before closing by giving you two things: a notice of termination and a copy of the lender's written statement giving the reasons for its decision. If the buyer does both, the earnest money is refunded. A buyer can give up that right with a separate Texas addendum on the lender's appraisal, either in full or only if the appraised value is at least a stated amount. When they do, and the lender lowers the loan because of the appraisal, the buyer brings that much more cash. That addendum is not used with FHA or VA loans. With an FHA or VA loan, a different clause in the third party financing addendum applies: the buyer does not have to complete the purchase or lose the earnest money if the appraisal comes in below the amount that clause sets, and the third-day deadline does not apply. We read your contract with you the day the appraisal arrives, so you know whether the buyer can walk away, by when, and what they would be giving up.
If the option period is still running, the buyer can end the contract for any reason. If it has ended and the buyer waived their appraisal right, you are in a much stronger position.
Why luxury appraisals come in low
An appraiser values a home from recent sales of similar homes nearby. On a luxury home there may be few true comparisons: a different lot, a view, a recent renovation, waterfront, or a build quality that a nearby sale doesn't match. An appraiser working from the closest sales by distance and size can miss what made a buyer pay your price. Our luxury pricing guide covers why that happens and how we price with it in mind.
Asking for a reconsideration of value
The buyer's lender ordered the appraisal, so neither you nor we can call the appraiser and ask for a new number. What can happen is a reconsideration of value, a written request made through the buyer's lender. It works when it gives the appraiser something they missed:
- recent sales that compare more closely than the ones used, with the reasons they compare;
- features or improvements the report left out or got wrong, such as square footage, a renovation or a lot feature, with documents to support them;
- a factual error in the report.
A request that only says the price was fair rarely changes anything. We prepare the comparable sales and the documents; the buyer's agent and lender submit them. Some lenders also allow a second appraisal, but that is the lender's decision.
Renegotiating the price
If the value doesn't move, the conversation is about who covers how much. The options are the same ones any seller has: hold the price and ask the buyer to cover the gap in cash, lower the price to the appraised value, or split the difference. What decides it is what each of you would face if the contract ended. If you have a backup offer, or strong interest from other buyers, you can hold firmer. If your home would go back on the market after weeks under contract, a smaller concession can be worth more than starting over. We put each option on your net sheet before you answer, so you can see what each one leaves you.
Lowering the chance of a low appraisal
The best protection comes before the contract:
- Price from the sales an appraiser will use. Our pricing starts from the recent sales and the homes for sale now in your neighborhood, not from a hoped-for number.
- Answer condition questions early. A pre-listing inspection and documented repairs mean the appraiser and the lender see a home with no open questions about its condition.
- Document what makes your home different. A list of improvements with dates and costs, permits, and a floor plan with square footage give the appraiser what the public record may not.
- Choose offers with the appraisal in mind. A cash offer, or a financed offer where the buyer agrees to cover a gap up to a set amount, moves the risk off you. Our guide to multiple offers covers how to weigh that against price.
How you launch matters too. Some homes do best as a Compass Private Exclusive, marketed only within the Compass brokerage, or as a Coming Soon, marketed online through Compass.com and Redfin.com, before the home reaches the MLS. Others do best on the open market from day one. We'll tell you which one fits your home and why.
Talk to us before you answer
Joe and Cara Keenan lead every consultation, negotiation and closing themselves. Keenan Group at Compass is Austin's #1 Real Estate Team (Austin Board of Realtors, 2024), with more than 25 years in Austin real estate and $1B+ in career sales. If an appraisal on your home has come in low, call us at (512) 415-7653 and we will go through the contract, the report and your options with you.
Frequently asked questions
What happens if the appraisal comes in lower than the offer?
The buyer's lender will lend only against the appraised value, so the gap must be covered by the buyer in cash, by a lower price, or by a split between the two, unless a reconsideration of value raises the appraisal. Whether the buyer can end the contract depends on the financing terms in your contract.
Can a buyer back out of a Texas contract over a low appraisal?
It depends on the contract. Under the Texas third party financing addendum, if the property does not satisfy the lender's requirements, including the appraisal, a buyer can end the contract on or before the third day before closing by giving the seller a notice of termination and a copy of the lender's written statement of its reasons. A separate addendum lets the buyer give up that right in full or only if the appraised value is at least a stated amount. With an FHA or VA loan, a different clause in the third party financing addendum applies: the buyer does not have to complete the purchase or lose the earnest money if the appraisal comes in below the amount that clause sets, and the third-day deadline does not apply. During the option period a buyer can end the contract for any reason.
Can I challenge a low appraisal as the seller?
Not directly, because the buyer's lender ordered it. A reconsideration of value can be requested through the buyer's lender, with closer comparable sales or corrections to the report. We prepare that information for the buyer's agent and lender to submit.
Do I have to lower my price after a low appraisal?
No. You can ask the buyer to cover the gap, lower the price, or meet in between. The right answer depends on what the contract lets the buyer do and what you would face if the contract ended.
Does a cash offer need an appraisal?
There is no lender, so no lender appraisal is required. A cash buyer can still choose to get one, and can still end the contract during the option period.
Build a Personalized Austin Plan
Every household's Austin math is different. Start with a public plan, compare neighborhoods, schools, lifestyle priorities, and price bands, then save it when personalization matters.


