When more than one buyer wants your home, the best offer is the one most likely to close on your terms for the most money you keep, and that is not always the highest price on the first page. Compare each offer on the same handful of points: net price after any credits, how the buyer is paying, who carries the appraisal risk, the option period, the closing date, and what the buyer is asking of you. Then decide whether to accept one, counter one, or ask every buyer for their best terms by a set deadline.
Start with what you keep, not the headline price
Two offers at the same price can leave you with very different amounts. A buyer who asks you to pay part of their closing costs, contribute to their agent's compensation or give a credit for repairs is offering less than the number at the top. We put every offer on a net sheet, the same line-by-line estimate we build before you list, so you compare what each one leaves you after payoff, commissions, title, tax proration and any credits. Our net proceeds guide walks through each of those lines.
How the buyer is paying
Cash. A cash offer removes the lender's approval and, usually, the lender's appraisal. Ask for proof of funds that matches the price, from an account in the buyer's name or their entity's name.
Financed. Most Austin luxury purchases above conforming loan limits use a jumbo loan, and jumbo lenders look closely at the buyer's assets and the appraisal. A pre-approval letter from a lender we can call is worth more than a generic one. We call the lender before you choose: how far along the underwriting is, and whether anything is still open.
Contingent on selling another home. In Texas this is written as an addendum to the contract. It can still be the right offer if the price and the buyer's other home are strong, but it adds a second sale your closing depends on. If you accept one, we keep the home's status and the terms in front of you so you know where you stand if a better offer comes in.
Who carries the appraisal risk
On a financed offer, the lender will only lend against the appraised value. If the appraisal comes in below the contract price, someone covers the gap: the buyer brings more cash, you lower the price, or you meet in the middle. Some buyers say in their offer how they will handle a low appraisal, for example by covering a gap up to a stated amount. On a luxury home, where there may be few recent sales that truly compare, that promise can matter as much as the price. We cover what happens next in our guide to a low appraisal.
The option period and the earnest money
Most Austin contracts give the buyer an option period, set in the contract and often 7 to 10 days, during which they can inspect and walk away for any reason; if they do, you keep the option fee. A shorter option period and a larger option fee mean the buyer is more committed sooner. The earnest money is held by the title company and is at risk for the buyer once the option period ends, so a larger deposit is a stronger signal too.
If you had a pre-listing inspection, share the report with every buyer. Offers then come in with the known items already priced in, and fewer surprises come back during the option period. Our pre-listing inspection guide covers what usually comes up.
Closing date and leaseback
The right closing date is the one that fits your move. If you need time after closing, a buyer can agree to lease the home back to you for a set period, written on a separate Texas lease form for the seller. A buyer who offers a slightly lower price and the leaseback you need can be the better offer. We ask each buyer's agent about timing before the offers are due, so the terms you see already reflect it.
Accept, counter, or ask for best terms
Accept the strongest offer when it is clearly ahead on net price and terms. Waiting for more can cost you a committed buyer.
Counter one offer when it is close and one or two terms need to change. If two buyers each accept a counteroffer, you could be bound to two contracts, so countering more than one buyer at once needs careful wording.
Ask every buyer for their best terms by a deadline when several offers are close. Every buyer gets the same deadline and the same information, and we tell each agent what matters most to you, for example the closing date or the leaseback, without sharing another buyer's terms.
Keep a backup. Texas has a backup contract addendum. If your first buyer walks away during the option period, a backup buyer moves into first position without you starting over.
What we don't do
We don't share one buyer's price or terms with another, and we don't recommend deciding on personal letters from buyers. Letters can raise fair housing concerns, and they say nothing about whether a buyer will close. We compare offers on their terms.
Before the offers come in
How you launch shapes how many offers you see and when. Some homes do best as a Compass Private Exclusive, marketed only within the Compass brokerage, or as a Coming Soon, marketed online through Compass.com and Redfin.com, before the home reaches the MLS. Others do best on the open market from day one, with a clear date for reviewing offers. We'll tell you which one fits your home and why.
Joe and Cara Keenan lead every consultation, negotiation and closing themselves. Keenan Group at Compass is Austin's #1 Real Estate Team (Austin Board of Realtors, 2024), with more than 25 years in Austin real estate and $1B+ in career sales. If you have more than one offer in hand, or expect to, call us at (512) 415-7653 and we will put them side by side with you.
Frequently asked questions
How do I choose between multiple offers on my house?
Compare what each offer leaves you after credits and concessions, how the buyer is paying, who covers a low appraisal, the length of the option period, the earnest money, and whether the closing date and any leaseback fit your move. The highest price is the best offer only when its terms are as likely to close as the others.
Is a cash offer always better than a financed offer?
Not always. Cash removes the lender's approval and usually the appraisal, which makes the closing more certain. A financed offer with a higher price, a strong pre-approval and a promise to cover an appraisal gap can still leave you with more. Put both on a net sheet and compare.
Can I accept a backup offer in Texas?
Yes. Texas has a backup contract addendum. A backup buyer moves into first position if the first contract ends, for example if the first buyer walks away during the option period.
Should I ask buyers for their highest and best offer?
When several offers are close, asking every buyer for their best terms by the same deadline gives each a fair chance to improve. When one offer is clearly ahead, accepting it can be the better move than risking that buyer for a small gain.
Should I read letters from buyers?
We don't recommend deciding on them. Personal letters can raise fair housing concerns and say nothing about whether a buyer can close. We compare offers on price and terms.
Build a Personalized Austin Plan
Every household's Austin math is different. Start with a public plan, compare neighborhoods, schools, lifestyle priorities, and price bands, then save it when personalization matters.

