This property is no longer actively listed. We can help you find similar homes currently for sale, notify you if this property relists, or explore off-market opportunities in the area.
Why you're seeing this property: Unlike major portals that hide off-market listings, we maintain the most comprehensive Austin property database. View market history, neighborhood data, and discover similar homes currently for sale. #1 Austin Realtor Team 2024.
3 bed, 2 bath, 1,646 sqft on 0.16 acres in Tarrytown. Austin, TX 78703. Last listed at $950,000, sold November 12, 2021. Austin ISD.
About This Home
Multiples received. Offer deadline TUE 3:00PM, Oct 5. Great opportunity to build or extensively remodel in Tarrytown Oaks. Superb location walkable to Casis Elementary, Tarrytown Park, Casis Village shopping center, Howson public library and the post office. Property being sold "as is" for lot value. Lot size is 6,900 square feet or .158 acres per tax records. Come see for yourself whether this is the site for your new build or a complete renovation. Refrigerator, washer and dryer convey.
Tarrytown is a historic Central Austin neighborhood in 78703, five minutes from downtown and bordered by Lake Austin to the west. Median home price $1.95M. Austin ISD schools - Casis Elementary, O. Henry Middle, Austin High - and walkability to Deep Eddy Pool, Lady Bird Lake, and Mayfield Park.
The housing stock spans nine decades. Original 1930s-60s colonials, Tudors, and ranch homes sit alongside new construction and gut renovations on lots ranging from 0.15 to 0.3 acres. Lakefront properties on Scenic Drive and streets near Lake Austin command $4M-$15M+. The neighborhood's character has been protected by an engaged neighborhood association and the McMansion Ordinance, which limits building scale.
Daily life here runs on the water and the schools. Morning laps at Deep Eddy Pool (68-degree spring-fed water year-round), school drop-off at Casis, coffee at Tarrytown Pharmacy or Summer Moon, dinner at Jeffrey's or Josephine House without leaving the neighborhood. The Contemporary at Laguna Gloria and Lions Municipal Golf Course are a walk or short bike ride away.
What makes Tarrytown distinct from other luxury Austin neighborhoods: genuine walkability, a 90-year-old neighborhood identity, and Central Austin access that Westlake and Barton Creek cannot match. The tradeoff is Austin ISD instead of Eanes, and smaller lots than you'd find west of MoPac.
School District: Austin ISD
View Tarrytown neighborhood guide- Property Type
- Residential
- Year Built
- 1947
- Lot Size
- 0.16 acres
- Price / Sq Ft
- $577
Listing information last updated November 12, 2021.
Listed by Realty Austin
MLS# 1943742 • Closed
IDX inquiries: Keenan Group at Compass · (512) 415-7653
Properties displayed may be listed or sold by various participants in the MLS.
Highlights
Facts & Features
Interior
- Breakfast Bar
- Built-in Features
- Laminate Counters
- Open Floorplan
- Primary Bedroom on Main
- Recessed Lighting
- Dishwasher
- Dryer
- Free-Standing Gas Range
- Refrigerator
- Stainless Steel Appliance(s)
- Washer
- Water Heater
- Carpet
- Tile
- Wood
- Heating
- Central
- Cooling
- Central Air
Exterior & Lot
- No Exterior Steps
- Private Yard
- Hardi
- Plank Type
- Stone
- Interior Lot
- Trees-Medium (20 Ft - 40 Ft)
- Wood
- Slab
- Deck
- Roof
- Metal
- Lot Size
- 0.16 Acres
- Driveway
Financial
- Original List Price
- $950,000
- Price per Sq Ft
- $577
Utilities
- Electricity Available
- Sewer Available
- Water Available
- Water Source
- Public
- Sewer
- Public Sewer
Transaction History
3 records on file
Every recorded listing, sale, and lease at 2305 McCullough ST, whoever represented it.
- SoldMay 29, 2024Listed at: $3,399,000MLS 7627123
- SoldNovember 12, 2021Listed at: $950,000MLS 1943742
- WithdrawnListed 2021Current price: $950,000Original list: $950,000MLS 3795759
Prices shown are list prices. Closed sale prices are available to registered clients in accordance with ACTRIS rules.
Explore this area
Price & Listing History
Listing timeline with current price, original ask, and market time.
- Current list
- $950,000
- Original list
- $950,000
- Price movement
- No verified reduction
- Listed / DOM
- Oct 1, 2021
Tax Record
Public record data from county appraisal records. Market value can differ from assessed value.
- Assessed Value
- $2,447,863
- Assessment Year
- 2025
- Year Built
- 2022
- Parcel ID
- 000000118556
| Year | Taxes | Total Assessment | Land | Additions |
|---|---|---|---|---|
2025+147.4% | — | $2,447,863 | — | — |
2024+12.4% | — | $989,357 | $937,500 | $941,328 |
2023+13.2% | — | $880,000 | $989,357 | — |
2022+18.6% | — | $777,134 | $880,000 | — |
2021 | — | $655,303 | $500,000 | $277,134 |
Virtual Tour
Zoned Schools
Austin
O Henry
Casis
Zoned assignments come from the property school fields available to us. District context schools are shown only when an assigned tier is missing. Contact the school district directly to verify current boundaries and enrollment eligibility.
Excluded from this estimate: property taxes, home insurance, and HOA dues. Each requires verified amount, cadence or unit, source, and as-of details.
Illustrative down payment
20% ($190K)
Adjustable assumption - not a lending recommendation.
Home price
$950,000
Loan details
Luxury property intelligence
Keenan Market Position
A sourced read on Tarrytown pricing, timing, and property scale. No automated valuation claim.
List price
$950,000
Price per sqft
$577/sqft
Vs. Neighborhood guide reference price
-47.6%
$1.8M · Tarrytown neighborhood guide · reference price
Days on market
Not available
Original to current
No verified reduction
$950K original
Active inventory context
35 listings
Price Position in Tarrytown
Listed 48% below the Tarrytown neighborhood guide reference price. Tarrytown neighborhood guide · reference price.
Source: MLS Grid / Unlock MLS and Keenan Group review as of Apr 25, 2026.
Request Private Market AnalysisConnect 2305 McCullough St to the Austin Market
Tarrytown Neighborhood Guide
Lifestyle, schools, market context, and homes in Tarrytown
Tarrytown Homes for Sale
Active listings and buyer search context in Tarrytown
78703 ZIP Guide
ZIP-level neighborhoods, schools, lifestyle, and Austin market context
Austin ISD Schools
District guide, nearby schools, and homes by attendance area
Austin Home Valuation
Private Austin CMA, TCAD context, and pricing strategy
Seller Resources
Pricing, prep, launch timing, and Compass marketing strategy
Keenan Group Results
#1 ABOR Team 2024 with $1B+ career sales volume
